A pair of glasses on a table

This Homemade Silver Cleaner Removes Tarnish Like Magic

There’s no shortage of commercial silver cleaning products on the market these days. Those that I’ve tested generally do the job, but they’re messy, contain harsh chemicals, and if that’s not bad enough—they’re expensive! Good news. I have a simple homemade silver cleaner recipe for your lovely silver pieces—chains, earrings, bracelets, flatware, and heirlooms that’s cheaper, better, and definitely faster.

A pair of glasses on a table

A word of caution: I cannot recommend this method for cleaning jewelry adorned with gemstones or silver items with patina intended to be part of the intricate design. And this definitely is not not for non-silver costume jewelry. What follows is for cleaning silver.

Most important ingredient

There are lots of DIY recipes out there for cleaning silver. I’ve tried many, and the results have ranged from marginal to OK, but not great. One included a final step of scrubbing the items with a green Scotchbrite pad. No! Trust me, I did not need to test that because I know that a green Scotchbrite scrubber will scratch the heck out of silver (stainless steel, too!).

That being said, never forget that the most important ingredient in any DIY method is common sense. With that, let me tell you about the absolute best homemade method and recipe I’ve found—this works like magic!

Equipment

  • plastic or glass container
  • aluminum foil
  • microfiber cloth

Ingredients

  • 2 tablespoons washing soda (aka soda ash)
  • 2 tablespoons ordinary table salt
  • 1 cup vinegar
  • 2 cups boiling water

Instructions

  1. Line the plastic bowl, baking dish, or another similar non-metal container with aluminum foil—shiny side up.
  2. Add the washing soda and table salt.
  3. Pour in the vinegar, stir to mix.
  4. Carefully add the boiling water.
  5. Drop in silver items to be cleaned, making sure each one is completely covered and in full contact with the aluminum foil.
  6. After a few minutes—or as long as it takes—when it appears the tarnish has mostly disappeared, carefully remove items with kitchen tongs.
  7. Gently polish and shine with a microfiber cloth.

This recipe multiplies well for larger items. You may need to use a bucket or similarly larger vessel to ensure the items are completely immersed. And make sure it is well lined with aluminum foil. Do the math to multiply the ingredients.

What’s the magic here?

I’m no scientist, but my research reveals that when the tarnish on silver meets up with sodium carbonate, sodium chloride, and acetic acid and is then introduced to aluminum, an electrochemical reaction occurs. Not to get too technical or to appear that I might be a chemist, I am told that reaction can be expressed as  3Ag2S+2Al—>6Ag+Al2S3as. Impressed?

Sulfur-containing substances in the air cause tarnish. As that tarnish is released, it produces an odor similar to rotten eggs. You’re going to smell this the moment you drop the silver pieces into the solution (it goes away quickly). Hot water accelerates the reaction. I am convinced by what I’ve learned that contrary to what some might believe, this reaction does NO HARM to silver.

And now, for some images taken by me, your highly unskilled photographer.

 

A knife and fork

A random selection of silver flatware, highly tarnished from years of non-use and neglect.

 

Silver and Cleaning

Into the bath they go. Immediately the cleaning solution turns cloudy and gives off a pretty pungent odor, not unlike rotten eggs!

 

A pink umbrella

This fork, covered in decades of tarnish build-up, came out not quite as sparkly as the others. A good wiping down with a microfiber cloth was all it needed.

 

A close up of a knife

I left these pieces in the “bath” for about 15 minutes, rinsed, and then wiped them dry. So easy and such great results.

 

A close up of a bottle

 

 

A cup of coffee

I inherited this tiny silver child’s cup from my dear Scottish mother-in-law, a wholly devoted lover and collector of all things British Royal Family. She purchased this commemorative piece upon the coronation of George VI and his wife Elizabeth as king and queen of the United Kingdom and the Dominions of the British Commonwealth, which took place at Westminster Abbey, London, on  May 12, 1937. It was black as night (sorry, Mom)  before I tucked it into the bath along with the flatware. Such a precious treasure, now bright and shiny!

Best Commercial Product

Realizing not all silver items will fit in a bucket or bowl, and for those who prefer to buy rather than DIY, there are times you may need to use a commercial silver cleaning product. In that case, I highly recommend the metal polishing cream, Simichrome Metal Polish. It, together with your elbow grease, will do a great job on silver.

Simichrome does a beautiful job of removing surface rust from chrome, polishing aluminum until it looks new, even sprucing up delicate, heirloom family silver. And it won’t leave scratches or abrasive marks. In as little as 30 seconds, you can watch a small, faded item goes from dull, oxidized metal to a having a perfect mirror finish.

In addition to restoring the original luster, Simichrome also leaves an invisible, protective coating to prevent further tarnishing and help keep the shine much longer. A solid favorite for home, industry, auto, motorcycle, and antique users, Simichrome is the fastest, most effective metal polishing and cleaning agent in the industry today.

Simichrome is the least harsh commercial product I know of but also the most effective. This is what serious car enthusiasts use to polish the chrome and silver on engines. Collectors use it on their most highly-prized collectibles.

While Simichrome will also clean coins back to mint-condition, please do your own research to discover if bringing them back to like-new appearance will destroy their value. Remember the patina!


Everyday Cheapskate participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.

 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

More from Everyday Cheapskate

garden seed starting table scape succulents tools gardener gardening hacks
DIY muffin liner homemade tulip baking lavender cutting board shadows
spa day at home mother daughter manicure hot rollers on couch
spring cleaning creative bright concept. tools, bottles, flowers, chalkboard with words hello spring
Unrecognizable woman cleaning with vinegar
wood floor with area rug
BKF cleaning a Stainless surface


Please keep your comments positive, encouraging, helpful, brief,
and on-topic in keeping with EC Commenting Guidelines



Last update on 2024-04-24 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Caught yourself reading all the way 'til the end? Why not share with a friend.

10 replies
  1. Holly Larsen says:

    V8 juice, ketchup, any old tomato-based product will safely clean silver, brass, and other metals.
    Discovered this when I spilt spaghetti sauce on my brass table.
    Just smear it on and wait while it does it’s magic!

    Reply
  2. Wendy says:

    I was surprised and delighted to see a picture of my mother’s silver pattern in your article! It’s the small salad/dessert fork. She received the set in a cherry wood chest as a leaving gift when she left the business where she worked in Pittsburgh,Pa. She left her job to get married sometime in the 1940’s.
    She passed away in 1965, so I am happy to have her “good silver “.
    Thank you for the silver cleaner recipe, and all that you do.

    Reply
  3. Candie Wiser says:

    I had always cleaned my gold wedding ring and the diamond with toothpaste and a toothbrush. I was in my bathroom one day and was thinking about my tarnished earrings. I heard toothpaste could clean them. Sure enough, I put toothpaste on the earring and let it sit for a few minutes. I took a rag, rub the toothpaste off and all the tarnish came off. I was surprised!

    Reply
  4. Janine Heater says:

    I just tried the washing soda, salt, vinegar, and boiling water method of polishing my tarnished silver. It works amazing well!
    I pre-mixed the salt, soda and vinegar in an 8 cup measuring bowl before pouring it over the silverware in the foil-lined glass baking dish. One caveat—when I poured the vinegar into the washing soda and salt, it foamed up and almost overflowed. Was that because I didn’t mix it in the foil-lined container?

    Reply
    • Mary Hunt says:

      I don’t know of a way to clean tarnish from silver in the dishwasher. But for the large piece of your inquiry, I recommend Simichrome Metal Polish plus a bit of elbow grease! It is fantastic and will keep your silver pieces tarnish-free longer. Hope that helps!

      Reply
  5. Barbara says:

    Hi Mary, I have a business polishing silver for people, TheMemphisSilverLady.com (I’ve been a reader for many years, ever since you were Cheapskate Monthly!) A couple of points about cleaning silver – first, start out by washing the silver with original Blue Dawn dish washing liquid in warm water. It is important to get the dirt and grease off first. Also, if people are using vinegar, it is very acidic and can pit silver, especially knives. Your suggestion is quick, but polishing with a good liquid or cream designed for silver is preferred, followed by a quick clean with a silver cloth on a regular basis. Thank you, Barbara

    Reply
    • Jan Taylor says:

      Barbara, are you willing to share the brand of your opinion of the best brand cream of liquid? I like fast acting and to be able to rinse off the residue with warm water.
      Thank you!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *