Worried young housewife and repairman near broken washing machine at home kitchen

Should You Repair or Replace Your Broken Appliances?

You’re worried the washing machine may be on its last spin cycle. It makes a horrible screeching sound and needs a lot of coaxing to make it all the way through a full cycle. Should you spend the money to fix this inefficient appliance or replace it with a new, high-efficiency model that will use less electricity and water?

Worried young housewife and repairman near broken washing machine at home kitchen

Fact of life

Face it. Home appliances, unlike fine wine, get worse with age. And most often, the older the appliance is, the more extensive and expensive the repairs. That means that each repair will return less and less on your investment over time.

Deciding whether to repair or replace your broken appliance—especially when trying to discover which option will save money in the long run—can be challenging.

Consider these basic guidelines and suggestions to help you decide, based on costs for replacement and repairs and the advantages of new models.

If you cannot pay cash

If you cannot pay cash for the new replacement, you should get it repaired to buy yourself time to save up for the replacement.

Even if the repairs only keep this appliance going for a year or two, you’re far better off repairing while saving for a new machine than putting a new appliance on credit and paying double-digit interest for the next three to five years.


If you have some cash but not enough

Consider replacing your clunker with the best used model you can find for the money you have to spend. Check sites like Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist.org for late-model, well-cared-for used appliances. Find a used appliances store in your community, such as the Restore chain of Habitat for Humanity locations. Spread the word to friends and neighbors. People are constantly relocating— creating situations where they need to sell perfectly lovely, near-new appliances.

If the appliance is eight years or older

Once an appliance becomes elderly, usually it makes sense to buy a new one. However, if you have a high-end, older appliance you may want to repair it provided it is not repair-prone.

If repairs are costly

If the repair bill is more than half the price of a new product, you should consider buying new rather than repairing it. That means you need to do your homework so you don’t have to make this decision on the spot while the repairman is standing there tapping his foot!

Here again, the deciding factor will be whether or not you will have to go into debt to buy new. Don’t be afraid to ask the repairman about your options for a short-term repair instead of replacing the expensive compressor, for example. What can you do to buy us a few months or another year with this washing machine?

If the appliance is under warranty

Even if repairs will be only partially covered by a warranty or service contract, repairing is the way you should go. If it’s under warranty, call a factory-authorized repair shop. If not, an independent contractor will likely offer better service at a lower cost.

The costs for diagnosing problems and repairing home appliances have increased considerably in the last few years. This has made replacements with new models more common.

A word to the wise

Home appliances have built-in obsolescence. They don’t make ’em like they used to. It’s by design that life expectancy has gone down gradually over the years. Take refrigerators for example. They used to last for 30 years or longer. They were specifically designed and manufactured for that kind of lifespan! These days you’ll be lucky to get ten years. And, that’s with excellent maintenance and timely repairs.

100% Guarantee

I can give you this guarantee: Your appliances are wearing out one day at a time—one wash load, one load of dishes, one nice warm night in winter, a lovely cool day in the heat of summer. Without any hesitation, I can promise that one day something will break down. And more than likely it will be without warning and at the worse possible time.

Never assume you are beyond this guarantee. Plan on it. Prepare for it. Perform good maintenance so you know what your appliances are doing and where they are in their lifespans. Keep those manuals handy. Learn the repairs you can do yourself. Know who to call when the problem is beyond you.

Anticipate so you are not caught off guard

Anticipate costs to repair and eventually replace major home appliances. Create a special account designated just for future appliance replacement. Setting aside a small amount of money every month will give you cash options to make wise decisions when the time comes.


Everyday Cheapskate participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon affiliated sites.


Print Friendly, PDF & Email

More from Everyday Cheapskate

a homemade frittata in a cast iron skillet
house guest room bright white walls light window houseplant bed
DIY dusting spray womans hand wiping dusty wood surface with yellow towel
mothers day brunch overhead view scones bread fruit coffee
a fiddle leaf fig whose leaves are made out of dollar bills in a midcentury home low risk investment
companion planting calendula and tomato plants
midcentury modern bathroom clean bathroom
laptop with chalkboard with hot deals april 2024 piece of chalk best deals

Please keep your comments positive, encouraging, helpful, brief,
and on-topic in keeping with EC Commenting Guidelines

Caught yourself reading all the way 'til the end? Why not share with a friend.

6 replies
  1. george taylor says:

    PLEASE – remind everyone to make sure the extended warranty company of their appliances are going to send companies that will show up and will be ethical and honest. We bought the 5 year warranty with our very expensive refrigerator and our washer and dryer machines. When we needed repair the company assigned us to a local company in our area and they refused to answer the phone number given. When we finally obtained someone on the phone, they gave us an appointment and never showed up. This went on for weeks. This happened on two different occasions.
    So, do a review of both the company you are paying for the extended warranty and the company in your area that will be assigned.
    What good is paying for an extended warranty if they’re not there for you when you need them?

  2. Anonymous says:

    Thanks for sharing such a valuable post with us. I am gonna bookmark this site.I have also seen your post it is awesome!

  3. Chris says:

    Often times the best solution is to repair it ourselves using the Internet as a guide. My husband and I did not have experience repairing appliances, but with the use of YouTube or Parts Select online we’ve been able to diagnose and repair several appliances including our oven, microwave, washer, dryer and even some fan ceiling fans. It’s amazing and we saved a ton of money DIY.

  4. Nicole says:

    We moved into our house just over two years ago. Within the first six months we had an issue with the fridge /freezer. We researched it and replaced two parts ourselves. Less than one year later we had the same issue. This time we replaced three similar parts. If it goes out again I think we’re just gonna have to get a new refrigerator.

  5. Robyn says:

    In this economy, when something starts to go wrong, check to see how long it will take to replace it. When my daughter replaced her dishwasher last year, it took two months from sale to installation. When my sister’s freezer went, the wait was over three months, so she opted to repair. The repairman couldn’t come for days, so she ended up doling out most of the food to friends. When the repairman ordered the part that was needed, it was another wait.

  6. Victoria Jacobs says:

    Been there and, well, still making the now 11 year old Samsung Washer do its job. Late Spring of 2021 it began making a grinding noise. A little at first, and then more and more, during the spin cycles. We called repair, which cost $125 just for the house visit. The repair person touched a bunch of buttons and dials, the screen cycled through a bunch of numbers, and then we washed a load of laundry. No noise. We added several towels. Still no noise. After 1 1/2 hrs. the repair person said he couldn’t stay longer but he was sure the problem was the “brains” of the unit and it would be better to buy new.

    I got on YouTube. Some solutions were posted, but they included lifting the washer off the floor. The washer is very heavy. There was a lot of laundry to do, so I began trying different cycles. The short cycle made no noise at all – not one bit of grinding. So, with a few exceptions, I have used just the speed cycle, sometimes raising the run time from 15 minutes, to 18 or 21. Because the cycles are short I wash smaller loads but with only 2 of us in the house, that actually makes it easier to keep up with the laundry. For now, the now 11 year old washer is doing well.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *