I’m going to bet that Christmas is about the last thing on your mind. Am I right? And now you’re thinking about it. So am I. And I mean homemade Christmas gifts. Yes! What a great way to make the most of being homebound. Crazy idea? Not at all when you consider my absolutely favorite homemade gift.
Making vanilla extract is super easy, but it takes time to brew. Sure, in a pinch you can wait until the last minute and make it in your Instant Pot, but the most ideal results come with at last six months of brew time. Suddenly, we’ve got time. And boy do I have good news on the price of vanilla beans!
Finally, the price of grade B vanilla beans (best for making extract) is coming down. Significantly. I placed my order for 2020 gifting and 25 beautiful, grade B vanilla beans (best for making extract) arrived at my front door in just a couple of days.
- Glass jar with lid
- Gift bottles
What size glass jar?
Any size canning-type jar will do. It all depends on how many gifts you plan to make. Plan on 4-oz. of extract for a nice size gift. Since I make at least 24 gifts, I use large 2-quart (32 oz,) Ball jars for my brew.
Your vanilla extract will “brew” in the jar that you want to keep in a dark cupboard, but in a place that is handy as you will need to shake it up once a week during the brewing process.
What kind of gift bottles?
These 4-oz. amber bottles with black screw-on lids are my favorite for a couple of reasons: They look cool, and the amber color protects the extract from light. The 4-oz. size is very generous and makes for a great gift size.
These 5-oz. clear hot sauce bottles with black caps and shrink bands are also a great option.
- Vanilla beans
What is the best type of vanilla beans?
Vanilla grown in Madagascar is known for its high quality and the best flavor, although beans grown in Tahiti and Mexico make a fine extract, too. Grade B beans, surprisingly, are better than Grade A for extracting. They’re cheaper too. That’s why these vanilla beans are my choice for 2020.
We are a Everyday Cheapskate participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you., an affiliate advertising program. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases by linking to Amazon affiliated sites.
What kind of vodka?
You want a mid-range, unflavored vodka that is 40% alc/vol and 80 proof. Look for that on the label. And look for one that’s on sale. I recently purchased a 2-quart bottle Fleischmann’s Royal Vodka locally for $6.99 on sale. Perfect.
Here’s the simple process I use to make a big batch of pure vanilla extract:
Get some canning jars (or other large glass vessels with lids) and wash them well. Using a sharp knife, snip the ends off the beans (don’t throw the ends away).
Starting about 1/4″ from one end, slice each vanilla bean lengthwise to about halfway lengthwise, leaving the two halves connected. The point here is to expose the millions of tiny vanilla bean seeds that are packed inside the beans. Don’t remove the seeds and try to not let them escape.
Put the vanilla bean pieces (including the snipped ends) into the canning jar. I need a lot of vanilla extract, so I use two 2-quart jars with about 30 beans in each jar.
Using a funnel, pour vodka into the jar covering the beans in the liquid, up to about 2 inches from the top. Place the lid on tightly and shake it very well.
Put the jar into a cool, dark cupboard. Once a week give the jar a good shake to get those tiny seeds well distributed.
The longer the extract “brews” making sure to give it a good shake routinely, the darker it gets and the more intense the vanilla flavor and fragrance.
This is how it looks on Day One …
Day Three …
And Day Four …
This is how it will look when fully brewed, 4 to 6 months. And beyond that? It just gets better and better!
Using a small funnel, fill the gift bottles with the extract. Add a nice piece of vanilla bean to each gift bottle so it will continue to intensify, instructing your giftees to shake it regularly.
Vanilla beans will remain amazingly potent almost indefinitely, which means the brewing bottle with beans can be refilled with vodka to continue the brewing process.
To finish off some of these gifts, I used these very cool customizable labels from Avery. It was so easy to go online and use the companion templates and designs that come with the label instructions.
The results are quite amazing if I do say so myself. The embellishment I used here is this olive green raffia ribbon, which I love.
I am so excited that I know exactly what my homemade Holiday Gift for 2020 will be. Just the same as it has been for so long, it’s become a tradition—to the delight of those who are on the receiving end. These sweet bottles of awesomeness are easy to ship.
My best estimate is that 24 bottles cost around $4 per gift, complete. I plan to enclose a fabulous cookie recipe with each of my gifts—one that calls for lots of really good pure vanilla extract.
By the way, I never completely empty either of my big jars so that the beans that remain will be submerged until I get around to refilling them with vodka.
It appears that while I have fewer beans now (some went into the small gift bottles) I will have a never-ending supply of vanilla extract for baking, flavoring coffee and gifts throughout the year and beyond.
My original batch of vanilla beans from 2012 are still in my big jars! Because I add a bean or two to my gift bottles, the stash dwindles. Even so, I used those beans for seven years. Last year I added some new beans, and will do that now, as well.
Making homemade vanilla extract is not an exact science. Common sense tells me my now-8-year-old beans are tired—not completely spent—but need a friendly boost.
Vanilla beans just keep on giving. And giving!
More from Everyday Cheapskate
Please keep your comments positive, encouraging, helpful, brief,
and on-topic in keeping with EC Posting Guidelines