air fry guy

What is an Air Fryer? Why You May or May Not Need One

Air fryer recipes are sweeping the nation, but what is an air fryer? How does it work? And most importantly, do you need one? Here’s the lowdown.

air fry guy

What is an air fryer?

Several years ago, a well-hyped, “miraculous” kitchen appliance appeared on the scene—the air fryer (or is it airfryer)? Either way, the message in a nutshell—enjoy deep-fried foods without all the negative stuff like calories. Fry with air, they said. A new treat for your health—up to 90% less fat! One manufacturer promised “Healthy food for diet eating!” Imagine that—delicious, healthy, fried food without the calories. Well, not exactly.

One reviewer, whose opinion caught my eye, writes that an air fryer is a high-output Easy-Bake Oven for adults. Hmm …

How does it work?

An air fryer is a small countertop convection oven designed to simulate deep frying without submerging the food in oil. A fan circulates hot air at high speed, producing a crisp layer via browning reactions such as the Maillard reaction.

This rapid circulation makes the food crisp—similar to deep-frying, but without the oil. Some product reviewers claim that regular convection ovens or convection toaster ovens produce better results or that air frying is essentially convection baking under a trendy new name.

Convection oven

OK, I’ll be brave enough to say what most of us think: What is convection, why is that a setting on my oven, and when will I find time to figure out how to use it? Even microwave ovens now come with options for non-microwave cooking including settings for bake, broil, and yes, convection.

Surprise! If you have a convection oven, you already have an air fryer. They are basically the same thing with a convection oven being better for doing everything that an air fryer promises. A convection oven and an air fryer both offer high temperature plus wind!

The fan helps to circulate and create even heat. And the higher the temperature, the better the crispy, beautifully browned result.

Airfryer vs. convection

Airfryer

Air fryers are pod-shaped, small-ish, meant to sit on the countertop. An air fryer consists of a door on the front that when opened reveals a basket and a tray. The food to be air-fried gets placed in the basket. The tray catches residue, drips, crumbs, etc. The open-weave-like basket allows hot air to circulate more efficiently around the food items, which should be spaced out.

An air fryer handles food for 2 to 4 servings, generally. That probably means air frying in batches if you cook for a family. While French fries, chicken nuggets, wings, and other frozen pre-cooked battered fare are most popular in air fryers, most of these appliances come with instructions for how to air-fry “baked” potatoes, air-fry vegetables, and just about anything you can prepare in an oven, even cake.

An air fryer has a single fan, positioned at the top of the appliance. The temperature control on a basic air fryer typically goes to 400F.

Air fryers can be unreasonably noisy, and a bear to clean, depending on the brand. And it’s not a small appliance as countertop appliances go. Expect a good one to have a footprint of about 15-inch square.

Convection

A convection oven has multiple fans—top and sides, which makes for much more even cooking. It’s large enough to handle 2 servings up to 10 or 12 or more. Using a basket-like “pan” in the convection oven gives all of the benefits of an air fryer and more. A convection oven is easy to clean, especially if it is part of your regular self-cleaning oven. And takes up no room at all if it is part of what you own already.

Hate to Break it to Ya

Neither an air fryer nor convection oven is a deep-fryer. If you expect yummy, decadent deep-fried results from either of these appliances, prepare to be disappointed. But if you are not into deep-frying, and anxious to eat more healthfully, and are not even hoping for deep-fried results, you will love the heat+fan results of air frying.

You can get amazing results either way by adding a small amount of oil—spraying it on or tossing those veggies, meat pieces, etc., in oil. And you really can 80% less oil than deep-frying to create amazing results!

Don’t be fooled by “fat removal technology.” That just means fat and oil can drip out onto the drip tray. Nothing magic there.

A Case for the Air Fryer

If  1)you do not have a convection oven already, 2) you typically cook for 2 to 4 persons, and 3) you have ample counter space, an air fryer could be an ideal addition to your kitchen. I predict you will be thrilled with this new addition to your cooking space. And chances are great that you will quickly recoup the cost by cooking at home rather than eating out, picking up, or answering the doorbell.

A Case for the Convection Oven

If you have this option in your kitchen already, that pretty much speaks for itself! Why would you need an air fryer? A convection oven is going to give better and more consistent results because it is a full-on appliance, not a chubby countertop appliance designed to sit out next to the toaster.

A convection oven has greater fan-power, and that’s the key to this kind of high temperature, powerful air circulation kind of cooking.

A convection oven rarely is a single-use appliance. Convection is a feature and part of a regular kitchen oven or microwave. And it frees up space on your countertop.

A Case for a Third Option

This is the best option I can offer if you do not have a good convection oven and desperately want to take up air frying. For about the same amount of money, you can buy a countertop toaster oven that has all the bells and whistles including an air fry option. Now you have a toaster, broiler, regular oven, convection oven, and to keep up with the industry, separate “air fry” option that comes with pre-settings.

This means you have an additional oven for when you are entertaining or on special holidays. You have an excellent toaster that can handle as many pieces of toast as desired. And you have an air fryer that can easily handle servings up to 8.

Best Inexpensive Air Fryers

Air Fryer

Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

More from Everyday Cheapskate

makeup-collage-1310x833
Dark hardwood flooring in modern living room
borax brand name and generic
bacon collage
air fry guy
organized kitchen drawer
exp sell by dates on food products
Woman cleaning refrigerator


Please keep your comments positive, encouraging, helpful, brief,

and on-topic in keeping with EC Posting Guidelines



Print Friendly, PDF & Email
17 replies
  1. atk says:

    I also was on the fence about purchasing an air fryer. I was watching a cooking channel in YouTube and the cook was experimenting with an air fryer. He said it was like a mini convection oven, and why heat up your large oven if you don’t need to? I have a gas/convection oven but it takes a long time to get to temperature. So I decided to purchase a small air fryer from Amazon, it was $39 and does not take up much space, although I do not plan on leaving it on my countertop. I’ve only had a few days. I reheated some baked chicken and it was delicious without using my big oven. I am very happy with my purchase.

    Reply
  2. April says:

    I have an air fryer sold by pampered chef. I love it because it is a dehydrator, rotisserie, air fryer and it bakes and roasts. I can do so many things in it.
    It actually sits on top of my fridge when I’m not using it. It is also very quiet.

    Reply
  3. TerriBee says:

    I own a compact Ninja air fryer and I love it because I don’t have to babysit a frying pan. No, it’s nothing like oil frying but my food comes out better. I put in a salmon filet with NO oil and it’s delicious. And to me the fryer takes less space than counter oven.

    Reply
  4. Betty says:

    Thanks Mary! I was really tempted to buy an air fryer what with all the ads about them for Christmas. The only thing holding me back was I didn’t want another appliance taking up that valuable counter space. And bonus: I have a convection oven already that I can use!

    Reply
  5. MaryE Ross says:

    Hi Mary, I have an Air Fryer OVEN & can not find many recipes specific to it. Mine is the one that folds ups after cooling. Can you help me with where to find some easy recipes? I did buy a cookbook but most of those were not ones we would use often.

    Reply
    • Mary Hunt says:

      You’ve identified another challenge with a specific air fryer! Recipes specific to the brand. I’ve just about concluded they’re best for heating up frozen pre-prepared foods like French Fries, chicken nuggets, wings, etc.

      Reply
  6. Janet Trippe says:

    This article was so helpful. I have been sitting on the fence and your insight helped me make my decision to not purchase an air fryer. I don’t have a lot of counter space and for my money I would rather invest in a toaster oven with convection ability. Thanksagain!

    Reply
    • Crystal Blackburn says:

      This year I bought an air fryer. I had been looking for one for some time. Since I don’t have any spare countertop space or extra power outlets in my kitchen, I decided to go with an air fryer/toaster oven/convection oven combo. (I was looking to use the combo unit as a replacement for my regular old, small toaster oven that I was using on pretty much a daily basis.) On Prime Day this year, I purchased the Instant Omni Plus from Amazon. (I got a really good deal compared to the regular price.) It’s made by the Instant Pot people. It has a stainless steel basket that is great to use for airfrying. There’s an enamel rack/pan that goes under it that can also be used separately. It also comes with a regular SS removable rack like full-size ovens do. The temperature can go up to 450 which is higher than a lot of the ovens. It makes great toast. It also has a rotisserie but I haven’t tried that yet. It can dehydrate but I haven’t needed to do that either. It can hold a 12-inch pizza. It has a light in it so it’s pretty easy to check on the progress of the food. It does take some getting used to cooking with convection. It’s so much faster. I really do like it. I use it a lot. The only bad thing about it was when I first started using it, I had trouble getting rid of the “new” smell before I could cook food. I had to keep heating it up until the smell went away. It was pretty bad.

      Reply
    • Betty Thomas says:

      I too have been on the fence. I have a smaller kitchen and countertop space is precious. That being said I do have a convection oven so this clears up all my questions and saves me from an unnecessary purchase. Thanks Mary.

      Reply
  7. Maria says:

    In the article, you said “Using a basket-like “pan” in the convection oven gives all of the benefits of an air fryer and more.”. Do you have a basket-like pan that you recommend?

    Reply
  8. Candie Wiser says:

    I have both an airfryer and a convection oven. My airfryer cooks in a shorter amount of time and food is crunchier. Tater tots are fabulous in my airfryer. I am wondering which one is more economical to run. An oven is so big, I would think it would cost more to heat up and bake than an airfryer.

    Reply
  9. Barbara Reed says:

    I have two air fryers. I actually like the results in my smaller basket one more than I do my oven one. I won’t go without one now.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *