40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 8: Make Your Holiday Baking Plan • Everyday Cheapskate

There are two kinds of Christmas baking.

The kind you love. And the kind you somehow assigned yourself.

Maybe baking is one of your favorite parts of Christmas. You put on music, pull out the old recipes and genuinely enjoy spending an afternoon in the kitchen.

Wonderful. Keep it.

Or maybe every December you make five kinds of cookies, two candies and your aunt’s complicated fruitcake because…well, that’s what you do.

Meanwhile, nobody in your house actually likes fruitcake. We need to talk.

Today’s Challenge

Decide what Christmas baking is worth doing this year before you buy the ingredients.

We’re not baking anything today.

We’re making sure whatever you eventually bake deserves the money, time and kitchen mess it’s going to require.

Do This Today

1. Make your baking wish list.

Write down everything you’re thinking about baking or making this Christmas. Cookies. Candy. Fudge. Bread. Pies. Cakes. Treats for neighbors. Whatever normally lands on your list.

Need a few ideas? I have a whole collection of festive holiday baking recipes for homemade gifts with fudge, toffee, spiced nuts, snack mixes and more. Take a look, but remember: we’re making a wish list right now, not assigning ourselves twelve new projects.

Don’t edit yet. Just get it out of your head.

Now look at each one and ask: Why am I making this?

Maybe it’s a tradition Christmas wouldn’t feel quite right without. Maybe you need it for a party or dinner. Maybe people genuinely love receiving it. Maybe your family simply loves eating it. Excellent reasons.

And then there’s because I always do.

That one deserves another look.

2. Choose your keepers.

Now decide what you’re actually making. Not what a highly motivated imaginary version of you might make if December suddenly had nine additional days. You. With your actual calendar from Day 5.

If the answer is two things, terrific. If it’s twelve because baking is one of your favorite Christmas traditions and you’ve made room for it, also terrific.

The goal isn’t less baking. It’s baking what you actually want to bake.

3. Check what you have before making the shopping list.

Once you know what you’re making, pull out the recipes and check the ingredients against what you already have.

We’re not cleaning out the pantry today. Just look for what these recipes require: flour, sugars, chocolate, nuts, spices, extracts, leaveners, decorations, parchment paper and whatever else is specific to your list. Check freshness while you’re there.

Then make one shopping list for what’s missing. If three recipes need butter, add up how much butter you need before you shop rather than discovering halfway through Cookie No. 2 that Cookie No. 3 has cleaned you out.

And pay attention to specialty ingredients. If a recipe requires several things you’ll buy only to use once, that’s worth knowing before you’ve spent the money.

Quick Win

No time for the full plan?

Pick one Christmas treat your household would genuinely be disappointed to miss.

There’s your first keeper. Everything else can wait.

Homemade Isn’t Automatically Cheaper

This is one Christmas assumption worth retiring. Sometimes homemade absolutely saves money. Sometimes it doesn’t.

Butter, nuts, chocolate, specialty ingredients and packaging all count. If you’re buying a long list of ingredients to make something you could buy for less, homemade may not be the bargain.

That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t make it.

If making Grandma’s cookies is one of the things you love most about Christmas, the value isn’t sitting entirely on the grocery receipt. That’s the point.

Maybe you buy the pie and make the cookies. Maybe you bake all afternoon because that’s your idea of a wonderful December day. Maybe you buy the cookies this year because something else matters more.

All perfectly respectable Christmases.

Why It Matters

Planning first prevents two surprisingly expensive Christmas habits: buying ingredients for things you never get around to making and buying ingredients for things nobody particularly wanted in the first place.

It also keeps something enjoyable from quietly turning into another obligation.

If baking matters to you, I want you to have time and money for the things you genuinely love making.

If it doesn’t? You have my permission to buy the cookies.

Your Turn

What’s the one homemade Christmas treat that’s absolutely worth the effort at your house? Tell us in the comments. Recipes and permission to quit are equally welcome.

Tomorrow

Tomorrow we’re turning our attention back to gifts. Instead of asking, What should I buy them? we’re asking a much better question:

What would they actually use or enjoy?

Because nobody needs another panic-purchased thing that spends the next three years living in a closet.

← Previous: Day 7 | Challenge Home | Next: Day 9 — Give What They’ll Actually Use →

More from Everyday Cheapskate

Christmas tree at golden hour with sun shining in window

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 40: Go Enjoy Your Christmas

Woman relaxing near fireplace talking on the phone at Christmas time

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 39: Reach Out Before the Rush Is Over

Woman relaxing with feet up with Christmas tree in the background

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 38: Know When to Stop

Woman finishing up wrapping a final Christmas present

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 37: Finish What You Started

Relaxed woman sipping on a warm mug of coffee with feet in cozy socks

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 36: Build a Little Christmas Buffer

Woman delivering a plate of pastries to her neighbor over the yard fence

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 35: Make Generosity Fit Your Life

Woman shopping on her smartphone with Christmas presents in arms

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 34: Don’t Let the Algorithm Shop for You

Woman looking at December calendar on her smartphone while drinking coffee

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 33: Recheck the Calendar and Reclaim Some Margin

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 32: Go See the Christmas Lights

Please keep your comments positive, encouraging, helpful, brief,
and on-topic in keeping with EC Commenting Guidelines

Barb says:

November 18, 2025 at 5:00 am

Every year I do the following: Both a sweet and savory Chex mix (I’m going to try Mary’s crock pot recipe this year), decorated sugar cookies, chocolate chip pb cup cookies, and some pretzel/caramel concoction, then whatever else I feel in the mood to make. There is always plenty of these to give as gifts to friends and family.

40-Day Christmas Challenge | Day 8: Make Your Holiday Baking Plan

Today’s Challenge