9 Easy Ways to Dress Up Store-Bought Desserts for Less
If dessert is still unchecked on your holiday to-do list, I have excellent news: the bakery has already done the hard part. Your job isn’t to reinvent pie. It’s to make it look as if it got invited to the party. And that can take less time than finding the good serving platter.
Here comes the holiday season, that wonderful time of year when we’re expected to decorate the house, wrap the gifts, entertain the relatives and produce magnificent desserts, preferably while humming Christmas carols and looking completely relaxed.
Right. And I suppose the laundry folds itself.
When time is short, there’s no shame in heading to the supermarket bakery for a little assistance. But here’s an idea I love: Instead of treating that purchased dessert as the finished product, think of it as your main ingredient. With a few inexpensive additions and a little imagination, you can turn something ordinary into a dessert that looks and tastes like your own creation.
And nobody needs to know how little time it took. Unless they ask. Then you can proudly reveal your brilliance.
Here are nine of my favorite tricks.
1. Give store-bought pie a little personality
A supermarket pie is already most of the way to dessert perfection. The crust is baked, the filling is done, and nobody had to clean flour off the kitchen counter. All it needs is a finishing touch.
- Pumpkin pie: Add small dollops of whipped cream around the outer edge just before serving. A light dusting of cinnamon or pumpkin pie spice makes it look beautiful. Have a few candied pecans? Chop them finely and sprinkle a little over the whipped cream.
- Apple pie: Warm individual slices according to the package directions. Top each with vanilla ice cream and a spoonful of warm cinnamon-brown sugar sauce (recipe below). It tastes wonderful, and the kitchen smells like you’ve been baking.
- Pecan pie: Drizzle individual slices with melted chocolate and add a spoonful of whipped cream. A tiny pinch of flaky salt over the chocolate is another lovely touch, provided you already have some.
My advice: Don’t bother decorating an entire pie if you’re serving it in slices anyway. A little attention to each plate makes an ordinary dessert feel special, and nothing gets squashed when you cut it.

2. Dress up a cheesecake
Plain cheesecake is one of the best bakery shortcuts I know. It’s delicious on its own, but it also provides the perfect starting point for all sorts of toppings.
Spoon cherry pie filling over the center, leaving a little of the cheesecake showing around the edge. Or warm a couple of tablespoons of raspberry or strawberry preserves with a teaspoon of water until they’re easy to drizzle.
Another possibility: Chocolate sauce and a scattering of chopped toasted pecans.
If you have a piping bag, add a few whipped cream rosettes around the edge. If not, spoon on small dollops. Nobody is grading your technique.
One warning: Cheesecake is rich enough already. You don’t need six different toppings competing for attention. Pick one flavor combination and let it shine.
3. Make brownies behave like royalty
Here’s a trick that works beautifully for holiday parties, cookie exchanges, and dessert buffets.
Buy a tray of plain bakery brownies and cut them into small, neat squares. Then, try one of these finishes:
- Drizzle with melted white or dark chocolate.
- Add a fresh raspberry to each square.
- Sprinkle with finely crushed peppermint candy.
- Dust lightly with powdered sugar using a small sieve.
Arrange them on a pretty plate with a little space between the pieces. What started as an ordinary brownie becomes a fancy little confection worthy of a holiday buffet.
A money-saving thought: If you already have chocolate chips in the pantry, use those. There’s no need to buy fancy melting chocolate just for a drizzle.

4. Give pound cake a promotion
Plain pound cake may not look terribly exciting sitting in its plastic bakery container. But slice it up and add a few layers, and you’ve got something worth bringing to a party.
Cut the cake into cubes and layer them in a clear glass bowl with whipped cream and sliced strawberries.
Repeat the layers until the bowl is full. A few berries on top finish it beautifully.
For a chocolate version, alternate pound cake with chocolate pudding and whipped cream. Sprinkle a few chocolate shavings over the top.
You can also make individual trifles in small glasses or jars. They’re especially handy when you’re serving a crowd and would rather not spend dessert time slicing and plating.
And if the pound cake is slightly stale? All the better for soaking up those creamy layers.

5. Turn cookies into sandwiches
Two cookies plus a little filling can become a completely different dessert.
Start with soft bakery cookies of roughly the same size. Spread cream cheese frosting or buttercream on the flat side of one cookie, then gently press another on top.
Roll the exposed edge of the frosting in miniature chocolate chips, chopped nuts, or sprinkles.
Chocolate cookies with vanilla filling are especially pretty, but oatmeal cookies with cream cheese frosting are delicious, too.
Want an ice cream version? Sandwich a small scoop of softened ice cream between two cookies, wrap individually, and freeze until firm.
This is one dessert I would definitely prepare ahead. Trying to assemble ice cream sandwiches while guests are waiting is a fine way to discover just how quickly ice cream melts.
6. Turn pudding cups into pretty parfaits
Those inexpensive individual pudding cups from the grocery store have more potential than you might think.
Spoon chocolate or vanilla pudding into small glasses, alternating layers with crushed cookies, whipped cream, or sliced fruit.
For a chocolate-cookie parfait, use chocolate pudding, crushed chocolate sandwich cookies, and whipped cream.
For a lighter version, try vanilla pudding, sliced strawberries, and crushed graham crackers.
The trick is using clear glasses so the layers show.
You don’t need special dessert dishes, either. Small drinking glasses, jelly jars, or even mismatched clear glasses work beautifully.
And there’s a practical bonus: Everyone gets an individual serving. No cutting, no scooping, and no debate over who got the biggest piece.
7. Turn doughnuts into dessert
Glazed doughnuts aren’t usually the first thing that comes to mind when planning dessert for company. Perhaps they should be.
Slice a plain glazed doughnut horizontally. Warm the cut sides briefly in a skillet, then allow them to cool.
Spread the bottom half with whipped cream, add a few sliced strawberries, and replace the top.
Finish with a little powdered sugar.
Now you’ve got something resembling a fancy bakery pastry, only you started with a doughnut.
These are best assembled shortly before serving. Otherwise, the strawberries and whipped cream can make the doughnuts soggy.
8. Make a cake look custom-made
A plain frosted cake from the supermarket can be a terrific bargain, particularly if you’re feeding several people. The trick is choosing one that isn’t already covered with elaborate decorations.
Remove any plastic decorations, if present, and consider adding fresh berries, chopped toasted nuts, or chocolate curls.
For a chocolate cake, try arranging strawberries around the top edge. For vanilla or white cake, a scattering of fresh raspberries or toasted coconut can look lovely.
One of the easiest tricks is simply moving the cake from its plastic container to a proper cake stand or platter.
Of course, don’t attempt to peel a fragile cake off its cardboard base if that means destroying it in the process. You can place the entire cardboard round on your serving stand. A paper doily can disguise the edge, and nobody will be the wiser.
9. Put together a dessert board
This may be the easiest idea of the bunch, especially when you need dessert for a crowd.
Instead of buying one large dessert, choose a few smaller bakery items and arrange them on a serving board or platter.
Try a combination of brownie bites, cookies, mini pastries, fresh strawberries, grapes, and a few pieces of chocolate.
Add a small bowl of caramel or chocolate dipping sauce if you have some.
The key is variety, not quantity. Start with what you already have, then buy only enough to fill in the gaps.
You don’t need a fancy wooden board. A large serving platter or even a clean, parchment-lined baking sheet will do.
Arrange the larger items first, fill the spaces with smaller treats and fruit, and you’re done.
It looks generous and inviting without requiring you to prepare three separate desserts.

Three inexpensive toppings that make a big difference
Before you buy special toppings, check the pantry. You may already have everything you need.
Quick cinnamon-brown sugar sauce
Especially good on apple pie, pound cake, or vanilla ice cream.
Ingredients
- 2 tablespoons butter
- 2 tablespoons brown sugar
- 1 tablespoon water
- ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon
Melt the butter in a small saucepan over low heat. Stir in the brown sugar, water, and cinnamon. Heat gently, stirring until the sugar dissolves and the mixture is smooth.
Spoon over warm dessert. This makes a small batch, enough for several servings.
Easy chocolate drizzle
Perfect for brownies, cheesecake, or cake slices.
Ingredients
- â…“ cup chocolate chips
- ½ teaspoon neutral-flavored oil
Combine in a microwave-safe bowl. Microwave in 15-second intervals, stirring each time, until smooth.
Use a spoon to drizzle the melted chocolate over your dessert. Let it set before stacking or transporting.
Cinnamon-maple whipped cream
An especially good match for pumpkin pie.
Ingredients
- 1 cup cold heavy whipping cream
- 1 tablespoon maple syrup
- ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon
Beat the cold cream until it begins to thicken. Add the maple syrup and cinnamon, then continue beating until soft peaks form.
Keep refrigerated until you’re ready to serve.
Of course, there’s nothing wrong with using prepared whipped topping instead. Stir a little cinnamon into it, and you’re in business.
And if chocolate sauce sounds especially good, I’ve got a wonderful recipe for homemade hot fudge sauce that you can make ahead and keep in the refrigerator.
What you can prepare ahead (and what should wait)
One of the best things about starting with store-bought desserts is that you can get much of the work done before anyone arrives. A little planning now means fewer last-minute projects when the kitchen is already busy.
- A day or two ahead: Shop for your desserts, checking package dates and storage instructions. Prepare chocolate decorations, chop nuts, and make any sauces you’ll be using. Refrigerate anything perishable.
- The night before: Cut brownies into neat squares, make cookie sandwiches, and assemble parfaits that will hold up well in the refrigerator. Keep crunchy toppings separate until serving.
- Just before serving: Add whipped cream to pies, finish desserts with fresh berries, warm sauces, assemble doughnut desserts, and arrange your dessert board.
One important reminder: Cheesecakes, pumpkin pies, cream-filled pastries and desserts with whipped cream or other perishable toppings need proper refrigeration. Follow package instructions, and don’t leave perishable desserts sitting at room temperature for more than two hours. If the temperature is above 90°F, that limit drops to one hour.
The easiest upgrade of all costs nothing
Before you spend another dime decorating dessert, try this: Take it out of the plastic bakery container. Put it on a nice plate, cake stand, or serving platter. Cut clean slices. Add a simple garnish if you have one. Wipe any drips off the plate before serving.
Amazing what a difference that makes.
And remember, the goal here isn’t to spend more money disguising a store-bought dessert than you would have spent making one from scratch. Use what you have. Keep it simple. One good finishing touch is usually plenty.
The holidays are supposed to be about gathering with people we love, not proving we can bake from scratch while simultaneously polishing the silver.
If anyone asks whether you made it yourself, you can tell them the truth. You had a little help from the bakery. And you took it from there.
Question: What’s the one dessert you’d happily let the grocery store bake for you?











Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!