Is Closing a Credit Card Hurting Your Score?

If you’ve ever tried to walk away from a credit card, you know it’s not as simple as cutting it in half and calling it good. There’s a right way and a potentially credit-damaging way to do it. Today, I’m answering your real questions about how to handle credit cards wisely, including how to close a credit card account safely when one no longer deserves a spot in your wallet.

Breaking up with a credit card? There’s a right way to do it and a few wrong ones. And guess what? The credit card companies really don’t want you to leave. Why? Credit card companies work hard to snag you and they work even harder to keep you. Why? Because once they’ve got you, they’ve got a stream of potential income from interest, fees, and spending habits. These companies paid dearly to bait, snag, and reel you in. Since that time, you’ve rewarded them handsomely.

They’re not about to watch you walk away without trying to charm you back into the fold (cue the 0% APR offers and cashback promises.) They’re counting on your inertia, confusion, or that tiny voice that whispers, “Maybe I’ll use it for emergencies.”

But if you’re serious about cutting ties, you’ll need more than scissors. You’ll need a strategy.

Is It Smart to Cancel Credit Cards You Don’t Use?

This is where things get complicated. You’ve probably heard, “Don’t close your credit cards! It’ll wreck your credit!” And while there’s truth to that, it’s not the whole story.

Too much available credit, especially if you’re not using it, can sometimes raise red flags. Lenders might wonder if you’re one rough week away from a spending spree. But closing too many accounts too quickly can ding your utilization rate, and that could lower your score.

The sweet spot? Keep your oldest cards open (they help your credit age gracefully), and close the ones that no longer serve you, slowly and intentionally. No mass breakups, just a polite “thank you, next” every few months.

Experts suggest closing no more than three accounts per year. Start with store cards from retailers that have gone out of business. Then work your way through the rest, beginning with the most recently opened ones. And please, check your credit score before you start. Knowledge is power.

How Closing Cards Can Affect Your Credit Score

Your credit score isn’t built like a sturdy oak. It’s more like a house of cards. One wrong move and the whole thing can wobble.

Here’s how closing a card might shake things up:

• Utilization Ratio: This is the percentage of credit you’re using compared to what’s available. Close a card with a big credit limit, and your ratio goes up, even if you haven’t charged a dime more.
• Credit Age: Lenders love long-term relationships. That old card you’ve had since 2003? It’s helping you, even if it’s dusty in the back of your wallet.
• Total Accounts: A healthy mix of open accounts shows you can handle credit responsibly. Slash too many at once and the system might flag you as a risk.

Bottom line: Credit scores are quirky. If you’re planning to apply for a mortgage, car loan, or anything major in the next 6–12 months, don’t start canceling cards just yet. Let sleeping scores lie.

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Close a Credit Card Account

Closing a card the right way takes more than a quick phone call. It’s a bit like sending a breakup text, then following up with a certified letter, just to make sure they really get the message.

Step 1: Make Sure the Balance Is $0

Don’t close a card while it still has a balance. You could trigger a rate hike.

Step 2: Call Customer Service

Call customer service (you’ll find the number on the back of the card or your most recent statement). Be firm but polite: “Please close this account and report it as ‘closed at customer request’ to the credit bureaus.” If they transfer you to customer retention, just repeat yourself. Record the full name of the rep and the date of your call.

Step 3: Send a Follow-Up Letter

Follow up with a physical letter that includes your account number, the date of your phone call, and the name of the representative you spoke with. Enclose the chopped-up card if you still have it. Send it via U.S. Certified Mail with signature confirmation.

Step 4: Follow Up Again

Wait about two weeks and call again to confirm the account is closed and reported correctly. They may drag their feet, so be ready to stand your ground.

Step 5: Verify Your Credit Report

About three months later, pull a copy of your credit report and confirm the account shows as “Closed by customer.” If it doesn’t, repeat steps 2–4.

Step 6: Celebrate

Light a candle. Play some Neil Sedaka. You’ve earned it.

When (and When Not) to Break Up with a Credit Card

DO consider closing a card if:

• It charges an annual fee you’re no longer willing to pay.
• It’s from a store you never shop at anymore.
• You’ve got several others in better standing.

DON’T close a card if:

• It’s your oldest card (helps your credit history).
• You’re about to apply for a mortgage, car loan, or major financing.
• You’re trying to lower your utilization rate.

Closing a card is a commitment. If you’re in an emotionally impulsive place (say, after opening a bill you forgot was on autopay), give it a few days. Rage-closing a credit card rarely ends well.

Tools to Monitor Your Credit After Closing Accounts

Once you start closing cards, it’s smart to keep a close eye on your credit. Mistakes happen, and unfortunately, they usually happen in their favor, not yours.

Here are a few tools I trust:

• CreditKarma.com: Free, easy, and great for monitoring changes over time.
• MyFICO.com: Not free, but you’ll get the real deal from the source that lenders actually use.
• Some credit cards and banks now offer free credit monitoring as a perk. Check your online account dashboard to see if that’s available to you.

No matter which tool you choose, check your report often, especially after a card closure. Make sure your account shows “closed by customer” and not “closed by creditor,” which can ding your score.

Identity Theft Protection: A Must-Have in 2025

If you’ve got a wallet full of credit cards, including a few you forgot even existed, you’re basically handing out invitations to identity thieves. And in this digital age, trust me, they RSVP fast.

That’s why I don’t just recommend identity theft protection. I insist on it. In my household, we use LifeLock, and have for years. They keep watch over our credit, flag anything fishy, and, if things ever go sideways, they step in to help clean it up.

It’s one of those “better to have it and not need it” kind of deals. Because when your personal info ends up on the Dark Web (ask me how I know…), you’ll want someone in your corner who knows what to do next.

• MORE: My Identity Theft Scare Started With One Email Alert

In Closing…

Credit cards can be helpful tools or financial traps, depending on how you manage them. The good news? You can take control of your credit story, one intentional decision at a time.

And remember: It’s easier to open a credit card than to close one, so next time you’re tempted by that 20% discount and a free tote bag, pause and consider the real cost.

Question: What’s the weirdest reason you’ve ever opened a credit card? (No judgment if it involved a tote bag. We’ve all been there.)

---

EverydayCheapskate™ is reader-supported. We participate in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and other affiliate advertising programs, designed to provide a means for us to earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.

More from Everyday Cheapskate

Please keep your comments positive, encouraging, helpful, brief,
and on-topic in keeping with EC Commenting Guidelines

Caught yourself reading all the way 'til the end? Why not share with a friend.