The Art of the Grilled Cheese Sandwich

A surefire signal that I’m out of town is the big square burn mark in my best stainless skillet. That’s the telltale sign my husband has attempted to prepare the one and only item on his repertoire of home cooked meals: A grilled cheese sandwich.

The man doesn’t know how to cook.

His grilled cheese sandwiches are burned on the outside, solid on the inside. Poor guy. When it comes to this basic all-American favorite, Harold does just about everything wrong. He starts with a blazing hot skillet, uses cold butter and unevenly sliced cheese with the thickest parts of the cheese piled up in the middle of the sandwich. This man really needs his wife.

There’s an art to preparing a perfect grilled cheese sandwich that is crispy, golden brown on the outside, soft on the inside with cheese that is evenly melted. 

EQUIPMENT: The best tool for this job is a well-seasoned cast iron skillet because of the way it heats evenly to create a lacy-crisp exterior on the sandwich.

INGREDIENTS: For one sandwich: Two slices good white bread, 1 to 2 ounces Cheddar, Monterey Jack or American cheese and about 1 tablespoon butter.

TECHNIQUE: Preheat the skillet over medium heat for about five minutes. While it is heating grate the cheese and sprinkle evenly between the two slices of bread. Grating the cheese ensures that it will melt evenly. Put the slices together and press gently to set. Melt the butter and brush generously on one side of the bread, making sure no spot is left unbuttered. Gently place the sandwich in the heated skillet, buttered side down. Turn heat to Low. The longer you can leave it without turning, the better the result. This allows the butter to brown slowly and evenly. In the meantime butter the top with melted butter. Once crisp and deep golden brown, brush melted butter on the top side, gently turn and repeat (5 to 8 minutes per side). Remove, cut as desired with a sharp serrated knife and serve.

GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH VARIATIONS: 

Grilled Cheese with Bacon. Fry 3 slices bacon until cooked but not crisp. Pat on paper towel to remove excess fat, add on top of the cheese, and grill as directed.

Grilled Cheese with Ham. Put 2 thin slices of ham between the cheese and grill as directed.

Onion-Cheese Sandwich. Follow the recipe for Grilled Cheese Sandwich, but lightly coat the inside of one slice of bread with Dijon mustard. Sauté 3 to 4 slices onion in butter and put on top of the cheese. Cover with the remaining slice of bread and grill.

Tomato-Cheese Sandwich. Follow the recipe for Grilled Cheese Sandwich, but add two thin slices tomato to the sandwich before grilling.

Grilled Mozzarella Sandwich. Two slices European-style country bread, 1-ounce Mozzarella cheese, sliced or grated; tomato slices or several strips of roasted red peppers and olive oil. Following the basic directions for the Grilled Cheese Sandwich above, sandwich the tomato slices (or pepper strips) between the cheese. Brush the bread with olive oil in place of the butter.

Greek Grilled Cheese Sandwich. Crusty bread (like sheepherder), 1-ounce feta cheese, crumbled; sliced tomato, basil or oregano leaves, ground black pepper, olive oil. Follow instructions for Mozzarella sandwich.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Caught yourself reading all the way 'til the end? Why not share with a friend.

3 replies
  1. launchman
    launchman says:

    We use our George Forman grill and it does an outstanding job. No flipping just close the lid and give them 5 to 7 min. Perfect

    Reply
  2. Linda Pries
    Linda Pries says:

    My most favorite grilled cheese sandwich is made in the oven. Your choice of bread, buttered on one side with your choice of sliced cheese in the middle placed on a cookie sheet and baked at about 350 until golden brown on the bottom, then flipped over, turn the oven off and wait until the bottom is golden again. In this way one can prepare as many as six sandwiches as once. I didn’t know there was any other way to make grilled cheese until I was in my 30’s because I had never had them any other way. I like for my bread to be crisp and not thin and flat the way it comes out in a skillet.

    Reply
  3. crabbyoldlady
    crabbyoldlady says:

    I’m sure this method makes an excellent sandwich, but for novices, it doesn’t really have to be this complicated. I use my teflon griddle, sliced cheese laid evenly on the bread and just butter the bread with a knife. The secret is low slow heat. My sandwiches are always perfectly golden, crisp and evenly melted. The variations posted sound delicious and will have to try some of them.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *