Turning Cast-off Clothing Into Cash

Posted on by Mary Hunt in Dear Mary 9 Comments

Dear Mary,

I have always donated our unwanted clothing, but with 2-year-old twin daughters who are outgrowing their clothes faster than I can change their diapers, money is tight. I’d like to bring their old things to a consignment shop to earn a little extra cash. Can you give me some tips on how to make the most money? Debbie, Michigan 

Family

Dear Debbie,

Make a list of the children’s consignment shops in your area, then do some research. Each will have its own unique policies on what clothes and condition of items they accept. Find out the terms—i.e., once an item sells, how will they split the proceeds with you? Do they accept only pristine condition items or gently worn? Must clothes arrive in dry cleaner bags or freshly laundered? Once you have all the facts, decide which shop you will try first. Make sure your items fit the store’s criteria, and make your first delivery. Keep careful records. Many shops have a policy that what doesn’t sell is given to charity unless you pick up the item in a timely manner.

Consignment shopping and selling is a great way to turn good items back into cash. Another way is through online consignment shops or an online auction like eBay.com. Or, you may find that selling your kids’ things at your own yard sale nets you more money for less trouble. You just have to experiment. If all else fails, remember when you donate to a qualified charitable organization, you are allowed to deduct the fair market value of each item from your taxable income. When you itemize your tax return, that can add up to a considerable amount and benefit you with a larger tax refund or smaller tax bill.

Dear Mary,

Since I turned 18, my father has warned me over and over about store credit cards. He says they try to reel you in with that initial 10 percent savings on a purchase, then slam you with high interest rates for a few chintzy perks. But lately I’ve seen store-brand Visa and Mastercards. Are those better? Britney, Georgia 

Dear Britney,

Not really. Most co-branded cards, unlike store cards, have an annual fee. And if it has no fee, watch out because the interest rate will more than make up for it.

Remember, stores are looking out for themselves, not you. Co-branded cards save them a lot of money over issuing their own credit card. Co-branded credit cards serve to strengthen customer loyalty by offering a variety of value-added incentives, and that encourages you to spend more because it feels like you’re getting something for nothing. The only way to make a co-branded credit card, or any card for that matter, work in your favor is to make sure it has no annual fee and that you pay the balance in full every month.

Do you have a question for Mary? Ask in the comments section here.

Exclusive Bonus!

The Best of Everyday Cheapskate Subscribe to email updates today and you’ll receive a link to download my brand new e-book, The Best of Everyday Cheapskate, FREE.

You’ll enjoy excerpts from each of my bestselling e-books to help you get onboard with saving time and money every day! 


Posted on by Mary Hunt in Dear Mary 9 Comments
  • Nancy Akerly

    I agree, Mary, about most credit cards. However, the only one I have kept is Target, which gives a 5% discount upon use, and then I pay the balance off every month. There is no yearly fee, so I believe this is a good deal!

    • kaetra

      I’ve often wondered about the Target card as I shop there very frequently for just about everything, even groceries. I always find the Target grocery prices considerably lower than regular grocery stores in my area. It’s been my aversion to store credit cards that’s kept me from opening a Target account. Do you get 5% discount on everything, including groceries? The only other credit card I have is Discover, which I pay off every month without fail. I’ve never paid them even a penny in interest and I’ve gotten over $1,000 cash back from them since 2007. I categorize every penny I spend into budgeting software on a weekly basis, which keeps me in control of my spending – and I really know where my money is going. For me personally cash seems to just disappear when I have it in my pocket and I never know where it went! However, being able to EASILY track every penny I spend on a card gives me the data I need to stay in control, stick to my budget and plan ahead. To each his own, you have to use the method that works best for you.

  • kathy in california

    Dave Ramsey advocates NO CREDIT CARDS at all–pay CASH for everything!

  • Priscilla

    Debbie, I have tried the consignment stores for my ladies clothes. The problem I found with it is that they price the items way too high and then they don’t sell. After 30 days they usually lower the price somewhat but it is still too high. i.e. they priced my used shoes at $14….no one bought them. Then if you want the clothes back you must pick them up by a certain date or you lose them. So be careful of that. A very few consignment shops will buy the clothes outright. I believe Plato’s Closet is one. Try to find one that does that and you won’t have to worry about checking back constantly to see if anything sold. Good Luck!

    • kaetra

      I’ve always felt the consignment shops in my area were overpriced too, so after trying a few times and not finding any good deals I just quit going. (I’m sure there are some good ones out there somewhere though.) Last year I used Goodwill’s website receipt builder to add up all the clothes and items I donated and I was very surprised at how much it added up to be. Granted you only get a portion of that back in tax reduction, but still, the Goodwill website made it so easy to find the value and build a receipt. It was MUCH less trouble than messing about with consignment shops, ebay hassles or all the work it takes to have a yard sale. (The one and only yard sale I ever had earned me exactly $2 per hour after I crunched the numbers, and it was extremely hard work. I particularly do not enjoy dealing with hagglers that try to talk you down on something you’ve priced for 50 cents for heaven’s sake! Ugh. So. Not. Worth. It.)

  • Priscilla

    Debbie, I forgot to say that if you have a “Mothers of Multiples” group in your area they usually put on sales where people can come shop for twins, triplets. Also, Moms-to-Moms have sales annually where you might be able to sell your things. My niece has twin boys and I’ve heard her talk about the group.

  • Erin

    With credit cards there is always the possibility that you will pay more and buy more than you planned for in the first place. Stores know this. If they can get you to pay later than you will buy more now. There’s just something more real about cash up front.

  • T

    Debbie: I own a consignment shop. I am the only shop in my area that carries clothes because they just do not sell. I quit carrying baby clothes altogether because they were just taking up space. If your clothes are in pristine condition and trendy, I would suggest taking them to your local Once Upon A Child store first. They will buy outrightt (Plato’s Closet is for teen clothes and they are very full and very picky.) Then see if you can locate a consignment shop that specializes in kids’ clothes, or have a garage sale. It’s kinda sad, but our country is overloaded with clothing. My shop is in a small farm town where people don’t make a lot of money, but there are still too many clothes floating around. And I cannot get teenagers into my shop for the life of me! I carry name-brand, like-new (sometimes new with tags) trendy clothes, but the kids are terrified that someone will recognize their t-shirt, or the item may be “so last season.” Oh, and I just heard of a website, Yardsellr.com, that goes through Facebook. I guess people are having good luck selling stuff on there. Good luck, I hope you sell everything and make lots of money!

  • Glory

    There are many “groups” on facebook that are set up as online yard sales. They can be hard to find until you know they are there. I’d suggest asking in your status for anyone who knows about these groups in your area, and then asking them to invite you to join. I have sold LOTS this way, and was able to pay a credit card with the money earned.